In-vitro testing for water resistance in sunscreens

By Katie Bird

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags In vitro Scientific method

An in-vitro method for testing the water resistance of
sunscreens has been developed that could provide a cost efficient
alternative to in-vivo tests whilst reducing the need for
human volunteers.

The increasing complexity of sunscreen products brings a growing number of parameters to be tested, and therefore an increasing interest in using in vitro​ methods, according to researchers. The study was conducted by seven international industrial laboratories and testing institutes and was an attempt to develop a simple, reproducible and reliable in vitro​ method to test the water resistance of sun care products. The test involved assessing the SPF of sunscreen products before and after water immersion, and then determining the percentage of SPF retention. If SPF retention is higher then 50 per cent the product is deemed water resistant, less than 50 per cent is deemed not water resistant. The method is similar to the in-vivo​ method where subjects are immersed for either 20 or 40 minutes, and exposed to doses of irradiation before and after the immersion. According to researchers this is a high stress procedure for the human volunteers making a reproducible in-vitro​ water resistance testing method a priority. The laboratories tested ten products, including different product formulations, such as gel, oil-in-water or water-in-oil emulsions, with SPF values from 12-50. Polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) plates were chosen to replace human skin although the researchers do concede that they do not exactly replicate the in-vivo​ situation. The sunscreen products were applied to the PMMA plates and then immersed in water. Measurements of SPF were taken after 5, 20 and 40 minutes. The researchers found that the conductivity of the water altered significantly the water resistance of the products, noting that osmosed water should be used for the experiments as tap water varies considerably geographically and seasonally. The reproducibility of the method was gauged by investigating the results from all seven laboratories on the same product, and in addition comparing these to available in-vivo​ results on the products. The team found that for the non-water resistant product results from all seven laboratories are very similar and match very closely the in-vivo​ values. For the standard water resistant sun product P2 (used as a standard by Colipa to test water resistance in-vivo)​, the difference in values between the laboratories was larger. Nonetheless, the water resistant claims would have been confirmed by all laboratories after 20 minutes immersion; however one of the laboratories did not find water resistance after 40 minutes immersion, according to the authors. The authors conclude that the in-vitro method proposes for the first time a 'relevant, convenient and ethical tool for the development of water resistance testing of sun products that aims to match the best performance​ in-vivo'.

Related topics Formulation & Science Skin Care

Related news

Related products

show more

See our latest innovations in personal care

See our latest innovations in personal care

Content provided by Covation Bio™ PDO | 02-Apr-2024 | White Paper

At CovationBio PDO, we’re helping the world achieve its sustainability goals by enabling better performing, better-for-the planet products across a range...

Collagen Reimagined, Discover Biodesigned Type XXI

Collagen Reimagined, Discover Biodesigned Type XXI

Content provided by Geltor | 20-Mar-2024 | Product Brochure

Collagen is the body’s most abundant protein and a mainstream ingredient for beauty. Type XXI collagen transcends a common protein into a powerful bioactive

Empowering natural barrier function for future-proof skin

Empowering natural barrier function for future-proof skin

Content provided by Lucas Meyer Cosmetics | 14-Mar-2024 | White Paper

Corneopeptyl™ is a new patented peptide biomimetic to the LCE6A protein, obtained by green chemistry-based synthesis. By mimicking the LCE6A protein activity,...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more


Beauty 4.0 Podcast